Playing With Fire

** Your front-row seat to the #miraculous and mysterious continues in our newsletter. Join the Into the Supernatural community. Subscribe here: https://intothesupernatural.substack.com **Find out more about the themes in this episode from our sponsor...

Former NYPD officer Pastor Andrew Columbia spent years in the heart of New York’s most violent streets, confronting crime, chaos, and what he now recognizes as intense spiritual warfare. But it wasn’t a moment on duty that changed him forever—it was...

What happens when God breaks through your everyday life?Viral creator Jimmy Darts joins Billy Hallowell and Jen Lilley for an unforgettable conversation about miracles, faith, and the power of ordinary generosity. From a supernatural healing of scoli...

What happens when a former Al-Qaeda leader becomes president of Syria? Joel Veldkamp of Christian Solidarity International (CSI) joins Billy Hallowell and Jen Lilley on "Into the Supernatural" to unpack the shocking reality unfolding in the Middle Ea...

From the outside, Jeannie Ortega Law had it all—major record deals, hit singles, and world tours with stars like Rihanna. But behind the glittering pop career was a life marked by deep spiritual warfare, pain, and a childhood entangled in Santeria an...

Astrology, crystals, “manifesting,” and psychic hotlines felt harmless—until they opened doors she couldn’t shut. In this gripping episode of Into the Supernatural, Billy Hallowell and co-host Jen Lilley sit down with Tailah Scroggins—a former New Ag...

What does it mean to stand in true solidarity with the persecuted church? Dr. John Eibner, President of Christian Solidarity International (CSI), joins Billy Hallowell and Jen Lilley for a powerful conversation on global Christian persecution, modern...

Is divine healing meant to be rare—or a normal part of everyday life? Evangelist and author Chad Gonzales joins Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell for a powerful conversation on why healing is God’s will for everyone, how to live free from sickness, and...

Welcome to the "Into the Supernatural" after show! Billy Hallowell and Jen Lilley dive into an epic conversation sparked by their recent interview with Bible scholar Rick Renner — unpacking everything from the rapture’s nine competing theories to anc...

What if everything you've heard about the rapture, the Antichrist, and aliens has a biblical explanation?In this mind-blowing episode of Into the Supernatural, Rick Renner joins Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell to unpack the rapture, the Antichrist, fa...

What does it really look like to live a life fully led by the Holy Spirit? In this powerful and deeply personal episode, Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell sit down with Abigail Robertson—CBN News journalist and host of Heaven Meets Earth—to unpack how s...

What happens after we die? In this powerful episode of "Into the Supernatural with Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell," author Randy Kay shares his stunning, first-hand account of what happened when he clinically died for over 30 minutes.After suffering...

What would you do if doctors told you that you were dying — and nothing could be done?In this powerful episode of Into the Supernatural with Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell, humanitarian and ministry leader Sara O’Meara shares her incredible testimony...

What happens when a high-ranking, Satanic priest has a direct, undeniable encounter with Jesus Christ?In this must-hear episode of Into the Supernatural with Jenn Lilley and Billy Hallowell, Riaan Swiegelaar shares his shocking testimony—from ritual...

In this gripping episode of Into the Supernatural, hosts Jen Lilley and Billy Hallowell sit down with evangelist Stan Lovins—a former baseball player whose life was radically transformed by a series of supernatural encounters with Jesus. From childho...